SC4 Picture Competition

[vortext]

whoops, just wanted to speed things up a bit 

Hmmm, is that rule still valid ? What do you think Arthur ?   

Challenge
If your picture loses, it can't be posted up again until at least five entire pages has passed (not five pages worth of posts, but five whole pages devoid of that picture).  You also can't post up a different picture to challenge one you lost to.   

Ps : Don't worry for me if the round keep going on 

There's nothing to worry about that, as I said above we'll talk about that rule with my fellow moderators, but no sanction will be take here, it's not like if you went against the site's main rules. - Arthur/ Moderator.

[kaylacey]

Vortext - 6
Yann077 - 3

[noahclem]

Vortext - 7
Yann077 - 3

[MandelSoft]

Vortext - 6
Yann077 - 4

[vester]

Vortext - 6
Yann077 - 5


Bringing the pictures over:
Vortext:


vs

Yann077:

[dohraymii]

I think the score should be Vortext 7, Yann077 5

Vortext - 7
Yann077 - 3

and then

Vortext - 6
Yann077 - 4

and then

Vortext - 6
Yann077 - 5

Looks like a vote was left off for Vortext

[art128]

Yes indeed! Thanks for pointing that out, Dohraymii!

So the current score is, if i'm not mistaken too.. ,

7 points for Vortext, and 5 points for Yann077.

[tabular type=6]
[row][head]

Name of Contestant

[/head][head]

Votes Cast

[/head][/row]
[row][data]

vortext

[/data][data]

7

[/data][/row]
[row][data]

Yann077

[/data][data]

5

[/data][/row]
[/tabular]

[jmdude1]

i will add another vote for yann. both are great pics.

vortext 7
Yann077 6

[Q-Tips]

vortext - 7
Yann077 - 7

[RickD]

So the decision is up to me:

vortext - 8
Yann077 - 7

[rooker1]

The rule makes perfect sense to me and we should continue to follow them, please.

If your picture has lost, than five entire pages should pass before you challenge again with the same picture to allows others to compete.
The second part of the rule is to allow more members to compete as well.  So if you have lost in the previous few rounds, allow others to get a turn to compete.

This is how I have always interpret these rules.

Allowing this round to contiue was the right thing to do Arthur.  Thank you for your help.
Robin

[Yan077]

Arf, once again, only one point missing to the enter the Hof ! 
Don't worry about the rule vortext, your picture is really beautiful and it was a great round 
Who will challenge your picture now ?

PS : Thanks for the clear explanations Robin, I totally agreed with your interpretation 

[vortext]

So apparantly, while it's okay to surf the web, posting on fora is a big no-no at work. Hence a shortlived reply from me earlier today.

Thanks for being a sport Yann! 
Still, I feel kinda bad for screwing over your rightfull place in the HoF.  Maybe I should've kept shut and let it drag on, sure someone was going to challenge eventually but with Arthur's remark in mind I felt compelled to speak out; the competition really is too much fun to let it go to waste. Also thanks Arthur & Robin for taking it easy, really appreciated it. 

So, who's up next?

[art128]

I presume i'll take the challenge.

[noahclem]

vortext - 1
art128 - 0

[SCWTC4]

vortext - 1
art128 - 1

[tag_one]

Vortext gets a vote from me as well 

vortext - 2
art128 - 1

[Yan077]

vortext - 3
art128 - 1

[Swordmaster]

Vortext - 3
Art - 2

[Dantes]

Vortext - 4 
Art - 2