SC4 Picture Competition

[sebes]

LOL cameron - looks like you are still in last contest...

My vote goes to Yoman: 4/4 tieing it up again....

[thundercrack83]

5-4, Yoman.

[Travis]

Tying it up. 

6-6

Whoops. 

5-5.

[Pat Riot]

You sure you don't mean tied up at 5-5? 

[threestooges]

Bringing the pics over:

Yoman:



Pat Riot:




As usual, both are great. The Christmas card is great, especially for the time of year. My one critique of it is that the words block some of the more "Christmassy" aspects of the pic. Yoman's pic is very clean (all the elements fit together well) and that single spur track really looks good. Given the season, I think I'll vote for Pat's.
Pat Riot: 6
Yoman: 5

[JBSimio]

I really like how Yoman's picture fits together.  The only thing that I can't take is the emptiness behind the industry there.  I'm also still in a pretty festive mood, so I'm going to vote for Pat Riot this time.

Pat Riot - 7

Yoman - 5

[bat]

I vote also for Pat Riot!

Pat Riot - 8

Yoman - 5

[metasmurf]

I love concrete misery, so I vote for Yoman


8/6 Pat still in the lead.

[Pat Riot]

3 more hours left   

[EDGE4194]

both are very good, i just wish the night mod wasn't used on pat's pic (it's too dark!),
but I'm still voting for the nice holiday scene.

9/6 Pat Riot

[Nardo69]

Coming out of my internet-free holiday I just saw that my pic made it untill round three! 

thanks for all who voted for me!

Now to the current one!

Nice pic but the night mod is a bit too much for me.

Yoman: The only I thing I don't like is that lonely catenary. You should either put that freight train on a siding, put catenaries on that lot with the factory and the siding or remove that lonely siding.

Other than that a great pic which is the reason why I vote for Yoman making it

9-7 in favour of  Pat Riot

Bernhard 

[DFire870]

9-8 Pat Riot

[Pat Riot]

its been 24 hours. should we just keep going since this round will be over in 1-3 votes?

[Ennedi]

Yes, 24 hours passed and you are the winner, Pat 
Congratulations!

(In fact you was the winner before DFire870 vote...)

The next challenger please! 

[tcx]

I'll challenge with this:



vs

Pat Riot:

[The_Hutt]

EDIT: Oops, Sarnath'd.

tcx, that's a tad bit too "generic" in that the buildings are mostly just boxes. Nothing particularly appeals to me there.

I'll go with Pat Riot's.

1-0

[ky72x]

I like the W2W buildings in tcx's picture, but Pat Riot's Christmas shot is very well done.

2-0 Pat Riot

[ManuelR]

2-1

[sebes]

Voting for TCX: 2/2 tied

[Pat Riot]

look at that, i won a round. only took me 10 tries