SC4 Picture Competition

[bat]

I vote for Art128's picture in this round:

[tabular type=2]
[row][head]Name of Contestant[/head][head]Votes Cast For[/head][/row]
[row][data]art128[/data][data]8[/data][/row]
[row][data]wes.janson[/data][data]1[/data][/row]
[/tabular]

[MandelSoft]

Arthur's picture is just more pleasant!

[tabular type=2]
[row][head]Name of Contestant[/head][head]Votes Cast For[/head][/row]
[row][data]art128[/data][data]9[/data][/row]
[row][data]wes.janson[/data][data]1[/data][/row]
[/tabular]

[thundercrack83]

I'll finish things off...

10-1, art128.

[XoX]

I take the challenge 

[dsrwhat316]

Bringing the pics over:

XoX:



vs. art128:



My vote goes to XoX: a very beautiful and detailed shot!

1-0 XoX

~ Dan

[Pat]

I will take this to a tie....

[tabular type=2]
[row][head]Name of Contestant[/head][head]Votes Cast For[/head][/row]
[row][data]XoX[/data][data]1[/data][/row]
[row][data]Art128[/data][data]1[/data][/row]
[/tabular]

[thundercrack83]

I'll go with XoX.

2-1, XoX.

[jmdude1]

and i will tie it up again with a vote for art128

xox - 2
art128 - 2

[Simpson]

I'm sorry arthur but my vote goes to Xox
3-2 in favor of Xox

[paroch]

Ah, that is not fair...... both pics feature some of my favourite buildings and props.  I often find that when there are two great (and they both are) pictures I look for things that are wrong...... and there is nothing wrong with either of them.

On the basis that I just like the way the old buildings face the square and the newer buildings have grown up behind them my vote goes to XoX.

XoX  4-2  Art128

(but Arthur your picture is also great)

[Nardo69]

Nothing to add to paroch's words from me so I am voting for Arthur (art128)  to egalize the score a bit - he is in the third round AFAIK ...

XoX  4-3  Art128

but that was a clear 50.0001:49.9999 decision ... 

Bernhard 

[tag_one]

Got to agree with Bernhard about the hard decision. Although both cities are very nice designed and both images are wonderful I like XoX's colorful composition a tiny bit more.

XoX - 5
Art128 - 3

[nerdly_dood]

Tag_one's opinion is similar to mine.

XoX - 6
Art128 - 3

[Ennedi]

Two really good pictures, maybe the best from some time 
Both Art128 and XoX made very good work with open spaces - interesting and realistic arrangement, perfectly placed textures (I don't see any imperfections and I know it isn't easy!)

XoX picture is more colourful (nice photoshopping btw!  ). But I like a composition of old and new buildings on Art128's picture.

Difficult decision. I think I'll do the same as Nardo ie. egalize the score 

[tabular type=2]
[row][head]Name of Contestant[/head][head]Votes Cast For[/head][/row]
[row][data]XoX[/data][data]6[/data][/row]
[row][data]Art128[/data][data]4[/data][/row]
[/tabular]

[sebes]

Ill go with Arthur - the row of trees is making that picture complete for me

6/5, XoX leading

[warszawa]

Two brilliant pictures but I'm making this a tie with my vote to Art128 as he deserves a spot in the HoF

[tabular type=2]
[row][head]Name of Contestant[/head][head]Votes Cast For[/head][/row]
[row][data]Xox[/data][data]6[/data][/row]
[row][data]Art128[/data][data]6[/data][/row]
[/tabular]

Alex

[Albus of Garaway]

I have to go with Arthur...

Xox: 6
Art128: 7

[CasperVg]

I'll tie it up again;

7 - 7

[wes.janson]

Even though I was taken to school with the picture... I'm a huge sucker for Gascookers market stalls.


[tabular type=2]
[row][head]Name of Contestant[/head][head]Votes Cast For[/head][/row]
[row][data]Xox[/data][data]7[/data][/row]
[row][data]Art128[/data][data]8[/data][/row]
[/tabular]

[canuck3360]

xox-8
art-8