SC4 Picture Competition

[ManuelR]

6-4 Tooheys

[oldrogue]

I'll make it

6 -5 tooheys

by voting for Mr. Rooker.....

[schm0]

Starting with Kitsune's post, the count was off.

May I suggest something? How about this format for keeping track of the score?:

username    X
username    Y

The score has been incorrectly kept twice on one page. 

Actual Score
Toohey     9
rooker1    2


Rooker1: Is that a custom lot? I'd love to see the whole thing. (Send me a link to a larger pic in a PM if you have one.) Did you shrink it? The pixellation is slightly noticable. The lighting is great, and so are the props. I can imagine a foghorn echoing off the water in the distance, or some sort of shady mob deal being made behind some of the crates. It's a long shot, but I'm pullin for ya!
Toohey: Too many shadowing and texture issues in the parking lot to ignore.  And, if you asked me, it's the central focus of the picture. The landscaping in the upper left is nice, though. Everything in the pic looks cramped, IMHO. 

My vote goes to rooker1.

Updated Actual Score
Toohey     9
rooker1    3

[rooker1]

I think the score is correct. 
The scores only ever increased by one point and the person ahead has always been tooheys, which is the reason his name shows up by each score.
It's not that the person voted for tooheys, it's that he is ahead still.

I believe the score is now tied at 6/6

Robin 

[thundercrack83]

The score was correct in this round, I believe that schm0 was talking about last round.

And bringing them forward...

Well I'll keep things rolling

rooker1



v

tooheys



goodluck robin

My vote is:

7-6, rooker1.

[JBSimio]

I really like both pictures, but those shadow issues kind of forced my vote for Rooker this time...

Rooker1 - 8

Tooheys - 6

[Filasimo]

man i cant help but stare at your seaport lots you keep spitting out Rooker. im gonna have to go with ya buddy

Rooker-9

Tooheys-6

[paroch]

Oooooh, that's a tough one - you both produce excellent work.

But on this occasion it has to go to Robin,

10-6 Rooker1 wins.

And with that, to the Hall of Fame I think.

We need 2 new pictures.

[ManuelR]

Oooooh, that's a tough one - you both produce excellent work.

But on this occasion it has to go to Robin,

10-6 Rooker1 wins.

And with that, to the Hall of Fame I think.

We need 2 new pictures.

No he's not in the HoF yet.
It was the second round.


We need a new challenger.

[Nardo69]

Okay ...

Robin



vs.

Me!



Have Fun!

Bernhard 

[TopCliff]

1-0 Robin. He deserves to be in the HoF.

[The_Hutt]

I'll make it 2-0.

[Nardo69]

1-0 Robin. He deserves to be in the HoF.

So, you think I don't deserve it ... ?   

[sebes]

You do to Bernhard - and this pictures is proof again...

But Robin goes first     3/0

[tooheys]

well done Robin  , thought I had you there for a minute 

Now for this contest, both show realistic views, but I have to go rural.

Robin 3-1

1-0 Robin. He deserves to be in the HoF.

Hmmm, are you saying this because Robin's pic is better than Nardo's, or just because you want Robin in the HOF (No offence to Robin or Nardo).
A comment like that makes it look like you are voting for a mate, suggest you vote and say nothing at all, or let us know a valid reason you like the
pic (ie like rural, like docks, like the layout etc etc)

[praiodan]

I'm with Bernhard on this one! Great attention to detail with those rail signals...!

3-2, Robin's still in the lead

[JoeST]

3 - 3 because that drainage ditch is just WOW AMAZING

[paroch]

Nardo gets it from me this time....

Rooker 3-4 Nardo

[dragonshardz]

4-4

[flame1396]

5-4 Robin

Very close... I'm a sucker for ports though.