SC4 Picture Competition

[warszawa]

Ejc for me, the picture is really realistic as it gives you an immediate idea that he has done some careful and awesome city planning.
BigBertas picture is an extraordinary effect , but I sort of prefer Ejc's a bit more.

BigBerta - 3
Ejc - 2

[M4346]

I vote BigBerta

BigBerta - 4
Ejc - 2

[superhands]

vote BigBerta

BigBerta - 5
Ejc - 2

[Russell]

Bigberta for me.

BigBerta - 6
Ejc - 2

[TheTeaCat]

ejc for me

BigBerta - 6
ejc - 3


TTC

[bat]

I vote for bigberta's picture:

7 - bigberta
3 - ejc

[Pat]

Bigberta

Debonair by night..

VS

EJC

Dortmund HBF..

8 - bigberta
3 - ejc

[paroch]

ejc for me.  Look at the detail in that pic.  That station and approach is amazing.

bigberta 8-4 ejc

[thundercrack83]

I'll go with ejc.

bigberta 8, ejc 5.

[sebes]

I'll go with Bigberta....

9/5, Bigberta leading

[wwecruz]

10/5 Bigberta

[rooker1]

I'll challenge with this one,


VS

[thundercrack83]

Robin (rooker1) for me.

rooker1 1, bigberta 0.

[Chrisadams3997]

That's a tough one, but I think bigberta's edges it out for me, though I couldn't give a specific reason for one against the other.  Maybe it's more... dramatic.

at any rate, tied 1-1

[Une_ame]

I like the buzy feeling one the harbour pic from Rooker1 (lots from PEG ?) but Bigberta's pic has another one that's even better (maybe the lights on the facades ?).

Rooker1 1,
Bigberta 2.

[callbat]

Wow, the (successful) incorporation of Polish  buildings into a Haussman ( "Paris" architectural style, for those of you who don't know, you silly people) dominated city plus the Lighting on the facade, combined with a very Soft softglow to emphasise rain plus of course the rain effect and the cloud layer, not to mention the amazing street layout, make Bigberta's one wonderful piece of eyecandy.

Therefore my vote goes to Bigberta



Rooker1 - 1
Bigberta - 3

[warszawa]

BigBertas picture stands out more than Rooker1s picture. They are both awesome, but BigBerta gets my vote.

Rooker1 - 1
BigBerta - 4

[threestooges]

I'll give my vote to rooker. Bigberta's pic is great, but rooker has done a great job creating a realistic freight yard (something which I have found to be rather tricky). The container stacks aren't too thick, a large number of cranes perhaps, but they all seem to have a function.
Bigberta: 4
rooker: 2

[vester]

Rooker gets my vote

4-3 in BigBerta's favour

[rooker1]

Une_ame, you stabbed me in the heart.  "Peg"........NO those are my own lots.

Robin