SC4 Picture Competition

[neongamer]

Oh goody, another pic to review!

I'll start on a possitive, by saying that I like the way all sidewalks all have matching textures. However, I'm not too overawed at the many contrasting colours and building styles. For me, this image is too vibrant. On that note, I place my vote in favour of Porter's station again.

1-0 to Porter.

[bob56]

they are both really good. For Porter's pic. The fog is amazing, but its just one building.  for arts, I really like the roundabout in the middle and the crane. i like the many more buildings.

I vote in favor of Art128

Art128-1
Porter-1

[sithlrd98]

I like them both , but I think porters is just a little better.

Porter - 2
Art128 - 1

[thundercrack83]

I'll tie things up again, with a vote for Arthur.

2-2, tie.

[Pat]

Hmmm 2 great artist competing here this round on one hand there is Arthur and the other is Jacob... Talk about Day and night wow!!!

• OK so here is what I am thinking Day (Arthur's Pic) I like the construction, the rail piece and the NUT's courts I believe? Anyway's I don't know if I see any real focus here in this picture at all?


• Now Night (Jacob's Picture) there is some good photoshoping here with what I think is either clouds at night over the train station or either a light snow falling... Now with this being a night pic the lighting is good with the station and the platform is well lighted up!!!

OK so with this all in mind here my vote will be going to Jacob here as the nite time works well for me and there is a good focal point...

[tabular type=2]
[row][head]Name of Contestant[/head][head]Votes Cast[/head][/row]
[row][data]Porter66083[/data][data]3[/data][/row]
[row][data]Art128[/data][data]2[/data][/row]
[/tabular]


Bringing pictures over to the new page...............


Art128's picture



VS

Porter66083's picture

[alan_vzla]

Porter66083 for me this time

Porter66083 4
Art128 2

[cogeo]

Art for me!

Porter66083 4 - 3 Art128

Sorry Porter, the BAT is excellent, but it's just the BAT.

[sebes]

Jacob / Porter for me.

5/3, Porter66083 leading

[Geronimo]

Good work both, this round my vote goes to Porter:

Porter - 6
Arthur - 3

[jmdude1]

i will add a vote for porters timebervale station.

porter66083 - 7

art128 - 3

[metarvo]

It's going to be porter66083 this time.

porter66083 - 8
art128 - 3

[tooheys]

I'll stick with Porter

porter66083 - 9
art128 - 3

[Sciurus]

Congratulations Porter!

Porter - 10
Art - 3

[tooheys]

I'll have a go:-

Porter66083



V

tooheys

[art128]

good round Porter 
hmm these two pic are really great 
I go for tooheys , because in Porter pic, there's no train on the track 
tooheys 1 - 0 Porter66083 
good luck for your both 

[jmdude1]

i really, really like porter's pic, it has that late night/early morning emptiness to it. tooheys pic is great too, a gentle grade leading up to the rail bridge, which has a train on it, its hard to beat a train on the tracks. imo, the pic could do without the boulders though.
i will vote for porter's pic again.

porter66083 - 1

tooheys - 1

[CasperVg]

Voting for tooheys...

2 - 1 > Tooheys leading

[Pat]

ooooooh no Dave you had to go against Jacob eeeks now this makes it a hard choice for me  .....  Since I have to vote for one pic and one pic only again...  Im stuck but I think I am gonna stick with Jacob on this... So with my vote I will bring this back to a tie.....

[tabular type=2]
[row][head]Name of Contestant[/head][head]Votes Cast[/head][/row]
[row][data]Porter66083[/data][data]2[/data][/row]
[row][data]Toohey's[/data][data]2[/data][/row]
[/tabular]

[N1_2888]

Nice sign on xannepan's Gare du Nord. But I vote für tooheys' picture:

[tabular type=2]
[row][head]Name of Contestant[/head][head]Votes Cast[/head][/row]
[row][data]porter66083[/data][data]2[/data][/row]
[row][data]tooheys[/data][data]3[/data][/row]
[/tabular]

[sebes]

I again for Jacob.  3/3 tied